The most common cause of counters being placed on permanents through something other than an effect is as a cost, usually to activate Planeswalker abilities. "An effect" meaning the resolution of a spell or ability. Proliferate is a keyword action introduced in Scars of Mirrodin. The most common cause of counters being placed on permanents through something other than an effect is as a cost, usually to activate Planeswalker abilities. This can get very deadly if your opponent has even one poison counter, or their creatures have -1/-1 counters! Proliferate is an ability and when it resolves it puts counters on permanents, that satisfies Doubling Season's replacement effect. Proliferate is a new ability made in the set Scars of Mirrodin. Someone in our EDH playgroup plays Atraxa, when they proliferate they double the amount of counters on a permanent.Say a Planeswalker has 4 loyalty counters, they'll double that to 8. "An effect" meaning the resolution of a spell or ability. It's any, and it's your choi… This site is unaffiliated. DMCA requests | One of the nastiest curve-outs this deck is capable of is a turn four Ezuri into a turn five Loyal Guardian . Effects are the results of a spell or ability, not the resolution of spells or abilities. Proliferate needs something to activate it. Privacy statement | Then, you cast Throne of Geth, a proliferate card. And proliferate doesn't just work with only one permanent or player. Terms of Use | Yes, any time an effect would create a token under your control or put a counter on a permanent you control Doubling Season will double it. You also have a Soul Stair Expedition down with two quest counters. A creature has 4 +1/+1 counters, they'll double that to 8, next turn the 8 will become a 16. Does it matter which enchantment was cast first? I hate being a pedant, but the rules of MTG are very precise and sometimes require it for clear understanding of interactions. This is what proliferate does: You may choose any number of permanents and/or players with counters on them, then give each another counter of a kind already there. Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. Each Proliferate trigger adds multiple growth counters because you add one counter to the Ascendency itself, then another for any other +1/+1 counters you placed on creatures. This matters in this specific case because there are static abilities and replacement effects that do not resolve, but do place counters on permanents that are doubled by Doubling Season. Magic: The Gathering Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. Help | If I have a creature with a +1/+1 counter and I then proliferate, with both [[hardened scales]] and [[doubling season]] on the battlefield, do I add an additional one from hardened scales and then double with doubling season or the reverse? After all, you get to choose which permanents and players get more counters. If you do, you can put a +1/+1 counter on Feral Hydra, a quest counter on Soul Stair Expedition, and a poison counter on your opponent! In the case of Throne of Geth, you must sacrifice an artifact. Feeds | TappedOut.js Blog Widget. It's any, and it's your choice . And proliferate doesn't just work with only one permanent or player. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. Contact | A short list off the top of my head are Hardened Scales, a second Doubling Season, "enters with counters" abilities such as on Primordial Hydra, Master Biomancer's ability, the ability that puts counters on planeswalkers when they etb, infect, and wither. You have a Ichorclaw Myr down and therefore your opponent has two poison counters. Articles and comments are user-submitted and do not represent official endorsements of this site.