We appreciate all you do for us. Mary's Chopped Chicken Salad $16.00 Grilled chicken, crisp romaine and iceberg lettuce, topped with diced tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers and roasted red peppers, with balsamic vinaigrette with a sesame crust. We have ordered once in April and today Mother's Day. Shared a personal pizza as an app, that was fine. Aside from that service was good. Less so since Covid. So tender and tasty. The red sauce was not great. Everyone enjoyed their dinner, in fact my husband ate his whole plate. Went back...again last night. Seafood Night. But it's got a well-stocked bar and offers a top notch Friday Happy Hour featuring an extensive selection of "Half Price Apps." First was three weeks ago. Excellent. We also had the spicy thai calamari as an appitizer. the same as in restaurant. Our waitress was great, the food was not. We do miss the good old days of eating there! We started off with the Margarita Flat Bread. As many times as we’ve been there you never feel like your anything but a number and not recognized with a greeting like “nice to see you”More, A century ago, this was the Steiger Inn (operated by the parents of Oscar-winning actor Rod Steiger) and was a going place... when I was a teen it had transmogrified into The Speonk Inn, more of a tavern than a restaurant. Little pockets of joy. Find the closest local pizzerias that deliver on Slice. The food was not that expensive. There was enough food for two meals. My husband had the panko crusted sole in a scampi sauce. Stopped in for happy hour it’s a beautiful place ... We sat at the bar and had some appetizers everything was amazing ! Reserve a table at Mary's Pizza & Pasta, Speonk on Tripadvisor: See 20 unbiased reviews of Mary's Pizza & Pasta, rated 3.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #2 of 5 restaurants in Speonk. Sadly it was not a good meal. The Chicken Marsala was nothing special. WOW! The Seafood Fra Diavalo had a fishy taste to it, the mussels did not taste fresh, dish tasted off. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. (And we r good cooks at home).More. Mary's Pizza & Pasta, Located at 190 Montauk Highway, Speonk. Laurie and ChrisMore. When I eat out, I’m not happy when I can say I could have made this better myself. We go to Mary's regularly so we are very happy to be able to pick up now without stress. Little pockets of joy. Nice to have a nearby neighborhood restaurant that offers ambiane and decent food choices. Drinks Menu. Really great food. We specialize in Italian/American cuisine. No entrees, while tasty, stood out as exceptional, and some were disappointing, notably the chicken on the Buffalo Wings Pizza. The bar area was packed. Find 1 listings related to Marys Pizza And Pasta in Speonk on YP.com. BAR. Spend an evening at the Bar and chose from a selection of Wines, Spirits and domestic and craft beers. Family owned and operated for over 20 years. We all enjoyed our evening out. So good! Brewology is a gastropub offering craft beers with a focus on high-level American cuisine. The atmosphere and evening crowds make our outside patio feel lively, and the place to be seen. Daily Specials. We specialize in Italian/American cuisine. The only thing is the back room where we sat was very noisy. GRILL. Click here to check out our Take Out and Catering Menus. Easy order and pay online for curbside pickup. 5.2K likes. We were excited to try it. Staff was friendly and swift. The decor and outdoor patio which was closed looked great. Upon personal observation, over...the ensuing decades the location has hosted a number of failed businesses, but since Mary's Pizza & Pasta opened there, it's been highly active and apparently successful. Best gnocchi we have ever had. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Marys Pizza And Pasta locations in Speonk, NY. Holiday Packages. We offer a full bar and happy WOW! The food was very good but the red sauce was not typical of real authentic Italian places we have been to.Caesar salad and mozzarella sticks were very good.More, 6 people dining for Valentines Day, Mostly all were pleased with food & service. The staff was friendly and very attentive. The Seafood Fra Diavalo had a fishy taste to it, the mussels did not taste fresh, dish tasted off. The only thing is the back room where we sat was very noisy. Delicious bread sticks to accompany meal. The service was very good and we did not have to wait long for our food and it was very busy. View Original Michelangelo menu, located at 295 Montauk Hwy, Speonk, NY 11972.